"What is it to talk to an author? "The problem of order
By Natalia Espinosa Flores
February 26, 2010 Bourdieu, Pierre. "What is to talk to an author? About Michel Foucault, "in Cultural Capital, school and social space. Mexico: Siglo XXI editors, 1998. Pierre Bourdieu
in What is to talk to an author?, By analyzing the case of Michel Foucault meets the objective of reflecting on the implications of the use of quotations, taking into account the field of production and reading of a work and how they relate.
The author starts by posing the problem, when making an appointment for what and for whom appointment? so that leads to reflection on the need to subject to criticism its function and determine what an author meant, when you said to whom. Bourdieu continues to highlight the importance of understanding the fields of production, reception and how they relate.
As the field of production, Bourdieu emphasizes attention to the time when he wrote a text, this relates to the academy and the position of the discipline concerned in relation to the others. Illustrates the latter drawing on Michel Foucault, who, as a philosopher, is dedicated to a discipline subordinate to philosophy, history. This serves as a transition point between the exposure of field production and reception. Foucault distances himself from historians for ideological reasons from his training as a philosopher, particularly their political philosophical radicalism. Bourdieu also makes a contrast between the reception of Foucault within universities and outside them.
ends with a reflection on the reception of Foucault's work inside and outside universities. Highlights the deficiencies Reading University in the first place not to read contemporary works are reduced to headings and key words, second is the role of teachers and a filter between what the author says and what the students receive, without achieving an understanding of texts. Bourdieu concludes with a question, can we really get a work?
agree with the author in the importance given to reflection on the field of production of a work, it allows us to approach the way in which the artist conceived by awareness of the structures within which was immersed, which, as Bourdieu notes, are in what he says. In understanding of the field after receiving about the readings we have been made of the texts, which influence the social perception people have of them, and therefore in our own reading. On the possibility of actually receiving a work, I think it is very difficult, if not impossible, to read a text as it was intended by its author. Although not think this is reason enough to say that there is no real acceptance of the work. All we can do is pay attention to the structures that shape a text and take them into account when interpreting it.
0 comments:
Post a Comment